Module compilation

From Coq Require Import List Lia.

Syntax and big-step semantics with de Bruijn indices, closures, and environments.

Parameter const: Type.

Inductive term: Type :=
  | Var: nat -> term
  | Const: const -> term
  | Fun: term -> term
  | App: term -> term -> term.

Inductive value: Type :=
  | Int: const -> value
  | Clos: term -> list value -> value.

Definition env := list value.

Inductive eval: env -> term -> value -> Prop :=
  | eval_Var: forall e n v,
      nth_error e n = Some v ->
      eval e (Var n) v
  | eval_Const: forall e i,
      eval e (Const i) (Int i)
  | eval_Fun: forall e a,
      eval e (Fun a) (Clos a e)
  | eval_App: forall e a b ca ea vb v,
      eval e a (Clos ca ea) ->
      eval e b vb ->
      eval (vb :: ea) ca v ->
      eval e (App a b) v.

CoInductive evalinf: env -> term -> Prop :=
  | evalinf_App_l: forall e a b,
      evalinf e a ->
      evalinf e (App a b)
  | evalinf_App_r: forall e a b v,
      eval e a v ->
      evalinf e b ->
      evalinf e (App a b)
  | evalinf_App_f: forall e a b ca ea vb,
      eval e a (Clos ca ea) ->
      eval e b vb ->
      evalinf (vb :: ea) ca ->
      evalinf e (App a b).

CoInductive coeval: env -> term -> value -> Prop :=
  | coeval_Var: forall e n v,
      nth_error e n = Some v ->
      coeval e (Var n) v
  | coeval_Const: forall e i,
      coeval e (Const i) (Int i)
  | coeval_Fun: forall e a,
      coeval e (Fun a) (Clos a e)
  | coeval_App: forall e a b ca ea vb v,
      coeval e a (Clos ca ea) ->
      coeval e b vb ->
      coeval (vb :: ea) ca v ->
      coeval e (App a b) v.

Abstract machine and compilation scheme

Inductive instr: Type :=
  | INop: instr
  | IVar: nat -> instr
  | IConst: const -> instr
  | IClosure: list instr -> instr
  | IApp: instr
  | IReturn: instr.

Definition code := list instr.

Fixpoint compile (a: term) (k: code) {struct a} : code :=
  match a with
  | Var n => IVar n :: k
  | Const i => IConst i :: k
  | Fun b => IClosure (compile b (IReturn :: nil)) :: k
  | App b c => compile b (compile c (IApp :: k))
  end.

Inductive mvalue: Type :=
  | MInt: const -> mvalue
  | MClos: code -> list mvalue -> mvalue.

Definition menv := list mvalue.

Inductive slot : Type :=
  | Slot_value: mvalue -> slot
  | Slot_return: code -> menv -> slot.

Definition stack := list slot.

Inductive transition: code -> menv -> stack ->
                      code -> menv -> stack -> Prop :=
  | trans_INop: forall k e s,
      transition (INop :: k) e s
                 k e s
  | trans_IVar: forall n k e s v,
      nth_error e n = Some v ->
      transition (IVar n :: k) e s
                 k e (Slot_value v :: s)
  | trans_IConst: forall n k e s,
      transition (IConst n :: k) e s
                 k e (Slot_value (MInt n) :: s)
  | trans_IClosure: forall c k e s,
      transition (IClosure c :: k) e s
                 k e (Slot_value (MClos c e) :: s)
  | trans_IApp: forall k e v k' e' s,
      transition (IApp :: k) e (Slot_value v :: Slot_value (MClos k' e') :: s)
                 k' (v :: e') (Slot_return k e :: s)
  | trans_IReturn: forall k e v k' e' s,
      transition (IReturn :: k) e (Slot_value v :: Slot_return k' e' :: s)
                 k' e' (Slot_value v :: s).

Inductive trans: code -> menv -> stack ->
                  code -> menv -> stack -> Prop :=
  | trans_refl: forall k1 e1 s1,
      trans k1 e1 s1 k1 e1 s1
  | trans_step: forall k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3,
      transition k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      trans k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3 ->
      trans k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3.

Inductive transplus: code -> menv -> stack ->
                     code -> menv -> stack -> Prop :=
  | transplus_base: forall k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2,
      transition k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      transplus k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2
  | transplus_step: forall k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3,
      transition k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      transplus k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3 ->
      transplus k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3.

Lemma transplus_transitive:
  forall k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3,
  transplus k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
  transplus k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3 ->
  transplus k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3.

Proof.

induction 1; intros; eapply transplus_step; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma transplus_trans:
  forall k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2,
  transplus k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
  trans k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2.

Proof.

induction 1; eapply trans_step; eauto. apply trans_refl.
Qed.

CoInductive transinf: code -> menv -> stack -> Prop :=
  | transinf_intro: forall k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2,
      transition k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      transinf k2 e2 s2 ->
      transinf k1 e1 s1.

CoInductive transinfN: nat -> code -> menv -> stack -> Prop :=
  | transinfN_stutter: forall n k e s,
      transinfN n k e s ->
      transinfN (S n) k e s
  | transinfN_perform: forall n1 k1 e1 s1 n2 k2 e2 s2,
      transplus k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      transinfN n2 k2 e2 s2 ->
      transinfN n1 k1 e1 s1.

Lemma decompose_transinfN:
  forall n k e s,
  transinfN n k e s ->
  exists n', exists k', exists e', exists s',
  transition k e s k' e' s' /\ transinfN n' k' e' s'.

Proof.

  intros until s.
  assert (
    forall m n, m > n ->
    transinfN n k e s ->
    exists n', exists k', exists e', exists s',
    transition k e s k' e' s' /\ transinfN n' k' e' s').
  { induction m; intros.
  - lia.
  - inversion H0.
  + (* No transition, use induction hypothesis *)
    eapply IHm; eauto. lia.
  + inversion H1.
  * (* One transition, we're done *)
    exists n2; exists k2; exists e2; exists s2. auto.
  * (* Several transitions, we're done *)
    exists 0; exists k3; exists e3; exists s3.
    split. assumption. eapply transinfN_perform; eauto.
  }
  (* Use inductive assert *)
  intros. eapply H with (m := S n); eauto.
Qed.

Lemma transinfN_transinf:
forall n k e s,
transinfN n k e s -> transinf k e s.

Proof.

  cofix COINDHYP; intros.
  generalize (decompose_transinfN _ _ _ _ H).
  intros [n' [k' [e' [s' [T TINF]]]]].
  apply transinf_intro with k' e' s'. assumption.
  apply COINDHYP with n'; assumption.
Qed.

CoInductive cotrans: code -> menv -> stack ->
                     code -> menv -> stack -> Prop :=
  | cotrans_refl: forall k e s,
      cotrans k e s k e s
  | cotrans_step: forall k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3,
      transition k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      cotrans k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3 ->
      cotrans k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3.

CoInductive cotransN: nat -> code -> menv -> stack ->
                      code -> menv -> stack -> Prop :=
  | cotransN_perform: forall n k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2,
      transition k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      cotransN n k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2
  | cotransN_trans: forall n n' k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3,
      cotransN n k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
      cotransN n' k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3 ->
      cotransN (S n) k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3.

Lemma decompose_cotransN:
  forall n k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3,
  cotransN n k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3 ->
  transition k1 e1 s1 k3 e3 s3 \/
  exists k2, exists e2, exists s2, exists n2,
  transition k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 /\ cotransN n2 k2 e2 s2 k3 e3 s3.

Proof.

  induction n; intros.
- (* n = 0 *)
  inversion H. left. auto.
- (* n = S n' *)
  inversion H. left. auto.
  right.
  elim (IHn _ _ _ _ _ _ H1).
  intros. exists k2; exists e2; exists s2; exists n'. split. auto. auto.
  intros [k' [e' [s' [n'' [A B]]]]].
  exists k'; exists e'; exists s'; exists (S n''). split. auto.
  eapply cotransN_trans; eauto.
Qed.

Lemma cotransN_cotrans:
  forall n k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2,
  cotransN n k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2 ->
  cotrans k1 e1 s1 k2 e2 s2.

Proof.

  cofix COINDHYP.
  intros. elim (decompose_cotransN _ _ _ _ _ _ _ H).
  intro. eapply cotrans_step. eauto. apply cotrans_refl.
  intros [k' [e' [s' [n' [A B]]]]].
  apply cotrans_step with k' e' s'. assumption.
  apply COINDHYP with n'. assumption.
Qed.

Compiler correctness, terminating programs

Fixpoint compile_value (v: value) : mvalue :=
  match v with
  | Int n => MInt n
  | Clos a e =>
      let fix compenv (e: env) : menv :=
        match e with
        | nil => nil
        | v :: e' => compile_value v :: compenv e'
        end in
      MClos (compile a (IReturn :: nil)) (compenv e)
  end.

Fixpoint compile_env (e: env) : menv :=
   match e with
   | nil => nil
   | v :: e' => compile_value v :: compile_env e'
   end.

Lemma find_var_match:
  forall e n v,
  nth_error e n = Some v ->
  nth_error (compile_env e) n = Some (compile_value v).

Proof.

  induction e; destruct n; simpl; intros.
  discriminate.
  discriminate.
  congruence.
  auto.
Qed.

Lemma compile_eval:
  forall e a v,
  eval e a v ->
  forall k s,
  transplus (compile a k) (compile_env e) s
            k (compile_env e) (Slot_value (compile_value v) :: s).

Proof.

  induction 1; simpl; intros.
- (* Var *)
  apply transplus_base. constructor. apply find_var_match; auto.
- (* Const *)
  apply transplus_base. constructor.
- (* Closure *)
  apply transplus_base. constructor.
- (* App *)
  eapply transplus_transitive; eauto.
  eapply transplus_transitive; eauto.
  eapply transplus_step.
    change (compile_value (Clos ca ea))
      with (MClos (compile ca (IReturn :: nil)) (compile_env ea)).
    constructor.
  eapply transplus_transitive; eauto.
  apply transplus_base. constructor.
Qed.

Compiler correctness, non-terminating programs

Fixpoint left_app_height (a: term) : nat :=
  match a with
  | App b c => S(left_app_height b)
  | _ => 0
  end.

Lemma compile_evalinf_aux:
  forall e a k s,
  evalinf e a ->
  transinfN (left_app_height a) (compile a k) (compile_env e) s.

Proof.

  cofix COINDHYP. intros.
  inversion H; simpl.
- (* Left subterm diverges *)
  apply transinfN_stutter.
  apply COINDHYP. auto.
- (* Right subterm diverges *)
  apply transinfN_perform with (left_app_height b)
                       (compile b (IApp :: k))
                       (compile_env e)
                       (Slot_value (compile_value v) :: s).
  apply compile_eval; auto.
  apply COINDHYP; auto.
- (* Application diverges *)
  apply transinfN_perform with (left_app_height ca)
                       (compile ca (IReturn :: nil))
                       (compile_env (vb :: ea))
                       (Slot_return k (compile_env e) :: s).
  apply transplus_transitive with
    (compile b (IApp :: k)) (compile_env e)
    (Slot_value (compile_value (Clos ca ea)) :: s).
  apply compile_eval; auto.
  apply transplus_transitive with
    (IApp :: k) (compile_env e)
    (Slot_value (compile_value vb) :: Slot_value (compile_value (Clos ca ea)) :: s).
  apply compile_eval; auto.
  apply transplus_base. simpl. fold compile_env. constructor.
  apply COINDHYP; auto.
Qed.

Lemma compile_evalinf:
  forall e a k s,
  evalinf e a ->
  transinf (compile a k) (compile_env e) s.

Proof.

intros. apply transinfN_transinf with (left_app_height a).
apply compile_evalinf_aux. auto.
Qed.

Compiler correctness, using coeval and cotrans

Lemma compile_coeval_aux:
  forall e a v,
  coeval e a v ->
  forall k s,
  cotransN (left_app_height a)
         (compile a k) (compile_env e) s
         k (compile_env e) (Slot_value (compile_value v) :: s).

Proof.

  cofix COINDHYP. intros.
  inversion H; simpl.
- (* Var *)
  apply cotransN_perform. constructor. apply find_var_match; auto.
- (* Const *)
  apply cotransN_perform. constructor.
- (* Closure *)
  apply cotransN_perform. constructor.
- (* App *)
  apply cotransN_trans with
     (S (left_app_height b))
     (compile b (IApp :: k)) (compile_env e)
     (Slot_value (compile_value (Clos ca ea)) :: s).
  apply COINDHYP. assumption.
  apply cotransN_trans with
     (S 0)
     (IApp :: k) (compile_env e)
     (Slot_value (compile_value vb) ::
      Slot_value (compile_value (Clos ca ea)) :: s).
  apply COINDHYP. assumption.
  apply cotransN_trans with
     (S (left_app_height ca))
     (compile ca (IReturn :: nil)) (compile_env (vb :: ea))
     (Slot_return k (compile_env e) :: s).
  apply cotransN_perform.
    change (compile_value (Clos ca ea))
      with (MClos (compile ca (IReturn :: nil)) (compile_env ea)).
    simpl compile_env. constructor.
  apply cotransN_trans with
    0
    (IReturn :: nil)
    (compile_env (vb :: ea))
    (Slot_value (compile_value v) :: Slot_return k (compile_env e) :: s).
  apply COINDHYP. assumption.
  apply cotransN_perform.
  constructor.
Qed.

Lemma compile_coeval:
  forall e a v k s,
  coeval e a v ->
  cotrans (compile a k) (compile_env e) s
          k (compile_env e) (Slot_value (compile_value v) :: s).

Proof.

intros. apply cotransN_cotrans with (left_app_height a).
apply compile_coeval_aux. assumption.
Qed.